Woblette

From California Criminal Law Wiki
Revision as of 23:26, 2 April 2017 by Sysop (talk | contribs)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

A woblette is a crime that can be charged as either a misdemeanor or an infraction. Penal Code 17(d) says a woblette is a infraction when either:

(1) the prosecutor charges it as an infraction,

or

(2) the court, with consent of defendant, determines it is an infraction.

Since there doesn't seem to be any language about when, it seems the court has the power to make it an infraction at any time.

Note that the court can only make it an infraction with the consent of the defendant. Because there is no right to trial by jury or right to appointed counsel in infractions, there may be reasons why a defendant would want the case to proceed as a misdemeanor. People v. Smith (2012) 205 Cal.App.4th Supp. 1 held the defendant must be notified about his right to proceed as a misdemeanor before the judge determines it is an infraction.

Penal Code section 490.1, petty theft under $50, is a special woblette, because according to People v. Campbell (2002) 104 Cal.App.4th Supp. 1, it's only reducible by the prosecutor; it can't be reduced by the court. PC490.1 is only an infraction "at the discretion of the prosecutor"; the judge plays no part in determining if it's an infraction. However, Campbell is an Appellate Division case, so it is only binding authority in Los Angeles Superior Court and persuasive authority for other counties. (People v. Corners (1985) 176 Cal.App.3d 139, 146.)

Violations of the San Diego Municipal Code are similar to PC490.1. SDMC §12.0201 says: "any such violation constituting a misdemeanor under this Code may, in the discretion of the City Attorney, be charged and prosecuted as an infraction."

There are some crimes which are listed as being a misdemeanor or an infraction, but are not listed in PC19.8, nor are stated to be subject to PC17(d), so it's unknown if they can be reduced to an infraction by a judge.

The following is a list of woblettes. If it's not listed below, it can't be reduced from a misdemeanor to an infraction. (People v. Dibacco (2004) 117 Cal.App.4th Supp. 1, 4.)

Code Crime Notes
BPC21672 Counterfeit sports cards
BPC25658(b) Purchase or consumption of alcohol by minor
BPC25658.5 Attempted purchase or alcohol by minor Removed by Stats. 2012 ch. 702 (AB2489)
BPC25661 Minor in possession of false ID
BPC25662 Minor in possession of alcohol
HSC11375(b)(2) Possession of designated controlled substance Not listed in PC19.8
HSC122335(b) Unlawful tethering of dog Not listed in PC19.8
PC193.8 Relinquishing car to drunk minor
PC272(b)(1) Contributing to delinquency of minor Not listed in PC19.8 but subject to PC17(d)
PC330 Gambling
PC415 Fighting, noise, offensive words
PC485 Not returning lost property
PC490.1 Petty theft < $50 Only reducible by prosecutor
PC490.7 Taking more than 25 free newspapers
PC532b(c)(2) False claim of military decoration by a veteran
PC555 Trespass upon posted property
PC597z Sale of dog under eight weeks of age Not listed in PC19.8
PC602(n) Trespass by vehicle Removed by Stats. 2012 ch. 702 (AB2489)
PC602(o) Refusing to leave property after being asked Added by Stats. 2012 ch. 702 (AB2489)
PC602(u) Entering unauthorized area of airport or seaport Not listed in PC19.8. Requires court to PC1385 the allegation
PC602(v) Avoiding airport screening Not listed in PC19.8. Requires court to PC1385 the allegation
PC602(x) Trespassing in neonatal unit Not listed in PC19.8. Requires court to PC1385 the allegation
PC602.13 Entering animal enclosure
PC652 Body piercing of minor without parental consent Removed by Stats. 2012 ch. 702 (AB2489)
PC853.7 Failure to appear
VC5201.1 Obscured license plate Added by Stats. 2012 ch. 702 (AB2489)
VC12500(a) Driving without a license VC12500(a) is a misdemeanor per VC40000.11, but subject to PC19.8. (b), (c), (d), and (e) can only be infractions.
VC14601.1(a) Driving with suspended licenese
VC23109(c) Exhibition of speed
VC27150.1 Sale of illegal exhaust
VC40508 Failure to appear
VC42005 Failure to attend traffic violators school